Here are just a few stories about the Nobel Peace Prize for Europe. Read some of these articles, or any others you find on Internet and send your comment about this with your personal opinion and, if you like, other opinions you have read (using reporting verbs).
Also please read other students' comments on this (unless you're the first student to post of course!) and make reference to what they say too, you might want to agree or disagree with what they say! If you find any good articles on this topic post the URL into your comments.
The Telegraph
BBC experts
The Guardian
NY Times
Global Voices
The Norwegian Nobel Committee decided to award to the European Union the Nobel peace prize for “six decades of contribution to the advancement of peace and reconciliation, democracy and human rights in Europe”.
ReplyDeleteThe news of the prestigious award to the European Union has caused different reactions, on one side those who fully agree with the unanimous decision by the Nobel Prize Committee and on the other side those who strongly disagree. Among critics, Lord Lamont said that the decision was “ridiculous and absurd” and Nigel Farage, the head of the UK Independence Party, said: “the Norvegians really do have a sense of humour”.
I immediately thought it was a nonsense choice, instead this award should not be viewed in the perspective of the difficult situation that Europe is currently going through.
The prize is like a “lifetime achievement award”. It is a recognition that should be seen in a long-term perspective. For instance how did people look at the future at the end of World War II and where we will be in the next sixty years if the European Union is not involved anymore.
It is true that the European Union has gone back and forth, has done some positive and negative things, has done some mistakes, think for instance the Balkan war in the 1990s, but also has achieved important goals, and if we take into consideration everything that has been done by the European Union, I believe that the outcome and the advantages are a lot more.
The European Union has brought economic prosperity towards European citizens and has maintained peace, life condition are a lot better, we have obtained the recognition of social rights and more democracy.
In a moment such as this, where the disintegration risk is real, it’s a very important award, like said Antonio Tajani, Vice-President of the European Commission: “The prize is an act of trust in order to maintain and continue the future and present efforts towards a more European integration”.
The same said Ulriche Guerot, European Council on Foreign Relations: “There is a symbolic component to the award, and also a promotional and supportive component”.
I honestly think that it’s important to continue looking for a better European integration but also a better way to handle any future enlargement.
What I find really interesting is that the members of the Committee are Norwegian citizens, but Norway on the other hand is not a European Union’s Member State.
Cristina Patron
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteEurope, what is wrong with you?
ReplyDeletehttp://youtu.be/b7xVDZk4ZOs
Few months before Europe awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, the European Commission released a video ( http://youtu.be/b7xVDZk4ZOs ) that was thought to promote the European enlargement. After few hours, the European Commission was forced to withdraw this video criticized for being racist, sexist and imperialist.
As we can see, the ad-video shows a white woman dressed in yellow (Tarantino must have been happy!) walking calmly through an empty hangar. Suddenly an aggressive Chinese man in the style of a kung-fu warrior jumps down shouting something that we can not understand. Immediately after, an Indian man in traditional dress goes against her wielding a scimitar. Then a black man kicks a door down and starts threaten the woman with the Brazilian martial art called Capoeira.
The woman still remains calm and gazes at her aggressors. Surprisingly, she multiplies herself turning into twelve stars forming a circle all around the “warriors”. At the same time, the men put their weapons away and sit down. Finally, even more surprisingly, the men disappear. There are only twelve yellow stars now: the stars of the European Union. The video ends with the slogan: “the more we are, the stronger we are”.
I watched this video for the first time while I was attending a German language course in Berlin. We did not know anything about this video because the teacher wanted us to discuss without any influence. Immediately after having watched it I thought that it was distasteful. I found it bitterly stereotyped and definitely racist. After having known that it was promoted by the European Commission, I felt terribly disappointed and speechless. I thought: “How could have this happened?!?”
First of all, I find the video clip extremely violence-soaked (due to weapons and to martial arts first and then also due to the implicit reference to Trantino’s movie Kill Bill).
Moreover, the main stereotype of this video seems to tell us that violence, threats and aggressiveness all come from non- European countries. There are also other gloomy stereotypes: violence is always carried by non-western or non-white men, white beautiful calm women should defend herself against black, Asian, Indian men and finally (and I find it dangerous and awful) those that are supposed to be better and more civilized countries (and cultures) should overcome and absorb those that are thought to be bad and inferior. Furthermore, the slogan at the end of it is directly linked to the concept of strength (both abstract and physical).
I am fully convinced that this video is an unforgivable mistake of the European Commission. “Growing together” (this is how the video was called) is a sign that shows there is something wrong with Europe.
When I think about the Nobel Peace Prize awarded by Europe, I can’t understand how this could have happened (again, like when I watched the “Kill Bill style video”). I can’t help but think about all the desperate migrants dying in the Mediterranean Sea, about the bad situation in Hungary, about rights that do not exist for some minorities (like homosexual people) in some European countries (like in Italy!), about European soldiers voluntarily involved in wars all around the world, about women and men arrested in Spain and in Greece for having protested against economic policy measures…
Therefore I think that Europe was not the best candidate for competing for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Well argued Agnese! I too was quite shocked by the video, it's unbelievable, really! You raise a lot of important issues about 'fortress Europe' and migration, rights of minorities and war!
DeleteThe 2012 Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to the European Union.
ReplyDeleteThis award represents the achieved results by the European Union to the advancement of peace, democracy and human rights in Europe. For over sixty years, States in Europe don’t fight wars.
In addition, it could be an appeal to the European Institutions and member states’ governments, so that it is necessary to continue the European integration process.
Nowadays the integration process has helped the reconciliation between states and historical enemies are now partners. The EU has had the role to transform Europe from a conflict area to a continent where there is a mutual recognition of different cultures. The conflicts have been settled by the European Union’s efforts to strengthen democracy, as a silent revolution.
As European Union a global actor, critics (and me) disagree about its absence in the Balkans war, but with the admission of Croatia as a new member next year and the opening of negotiations with Montenegro and Serbia, these are the outcomes of a long reconciliation process. In this way this award is an appeal to find again the “European dream” relaunching the integration process to the political Union and to the “United States of Europe”.
Francesca Villani
Last week the European Union (EU) won the Nobel Peace Price 2012. The Norvegian Nobel Committee ha decided that this Nobel Prize is to be awarded to the EU. But this important decision has been a surprise and it has created delusion in several countries of the world. Why this? Many people aren’t agree with the Norvegian Nobel Committee; on the contrary, many people think that the Nobel Prize 2012 has been wrong! In really, with this award the Norvegian Nobel Committee has wished to focus on EU’s most important result: the successful struggle for peace and reconciliation and Democracy and human rights. The EU has helped to transform most of Europe from a continent of war to a continent of peace.
ReplyDeleteBut today, in Greece and in other parts of EU there are grave economic difficulties and considerable social unrest. So, the Nobel Peace prize 2012 has provoked scorn from many corners following frequent anti-austerity riots that have flared on the continent. This particular political moment shows that, many times, the economics interest is more important than the social problems. The critic situation in some European countries, like Spain and Greece, is really dangerous: last week a man died during a public manifestation in Athens, against the European politics. There is a considerable percentage of people that think the Nobel Peace prize 2012 has been absurd. This award was right in the past when the EU guaranteed for the Democracy and this needed to enter in European Union (EU).
Mara Trevigne
I guess that what is really wrong here is not simply the fact that the EU won the Nobel prize. This alone could make sense if viewed within a certain prospective (mostly an hystorical prospective), but what I sense as almost disturbing is the sense of time that led the Norvegian Nobel Committee to this decision. As we all know were assisting (and involved) in a period of terrible crisis which is not only economical but also political. The euro struggles to be accepted by the same countries that wanted it so much, and its benefits are questioned almost every day. Citizens are oppressed by meaningless forms of austerity by governments with no benefits for the EU economies. Putting this prize in such picture make me feel like we are not in front of a simple Nobel awarding. It's like being a spectator of a massive advertisement campaign to promote the Union instead. That is why I felt rather disappointed when I read the news on this topic.
ReplyDeleteThe Nobel Peace prize was awarded to the E.U. It was assigned to the E.U for the effect that more than sixty years it has contributed to peace, reconciliation, democracy and human rights in Europe. After the two great and bloody wars there was a need for a new Europe: strong and united. There was the need for all countries to feel helped mutually. Perhaps give the Nobel Prize to he E.U led to trample all these values and principles (union, peace, solidity). The Nobel prize was given to man and women who fought and sometimes lost their lives to improve the human life. I think the Nobel Peace prize to the EU is an error of form and substance: form because means give it to an organization and it is also assignes to members who are not worthy; substance because peace is the absence of conflicts. there will be no more conflicts really?
ReplyDeleteBenfatto Elena.
Sometimes people consider the Nobel Peace Prize as being an instrumental award, designed in order to endorse a politician, a political ideology or an organization.
ReplyDeleteThis endorsement was made in 1993, when the Prize was awarded to Nelson Mandela, a guerrilla fighter and terrorist who gained the power in South Africa: the Nobel Peace Prize was awarded, likely, in order to strengthen his prestige and secure the transition from the whites-only Republic of South Africa to the "Rainbow Nation".
Sixteen years later, the Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to a US President who was at the beginnings of his mandate. Also in this case the Nobel Peace Prize was an instrumental award, and the so-called "POTUS" between 2010 and 2011 strengthened the US forces in Afghanistan against Islamic traditionalists, backed and supported the Bahraini repressions, backed and supported the Libyan insurrection, repeatedly threatened a sovereign State, the Islamic Republic of Iran, and still is backing and supporting another bloody civil war, in Syria, not to mention the US support to Georgia.
The 2012 Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to the European Union.
At first glance, the award could appear as purely instrumental: many EU Member States are involved in bloody wars. For example, France is steadily involved in peace enforcing missions in its African former colonies and in Afghanistan, not to mention the United Kingdom or Italy. Moreover, France, United Kingdom and Italy were also involved into the attack on Libya.
Moreover, the Balkan Wars have showed to the whole world the ineffectiveness of EU-foreign policy: EU Member States acted individually and this lack of union hardly proved the EU capacity to act jointly. Still today, four Member States do not recognize Kosovo as an independent country. Attempts to achieve an autonomous and properly European military and diplomatic instrument were made, but they all resolved in failures: from the Saint-Malo summit (UK-FR) to the deplorable lack of EU action in diplomatic and political crisis around the world. The only field where the EU could act as a whole is the external common trade policy, which unlikely is linked with peace enforcement around the world.
This discouraging depiction, however, cannot lead to the conclusion that the EU is not worth of the Nobel Peace Prize. For over sixty years, European nations have not fought wars. At the beginning of the European construction, all Member States were too weak to fight anything more than a limited insurgency, but later, when the reconstruction was launched, the most important nations decided to plan a common economic space, in order to eliminate any resources-related reason to conduct a intra-European war: Germany offered its coal, France offered its industrial apparatus. By a sign, the 70 years long war reasons were overwhelmed by the desire of a peaceful cooperation.
This achievement is not enough. Without a real European political union, which has to go far beyond current “integration” and supranational construction, the threat of a war cannot be averted definitively, since the “Lords of treaties” remain the Member States, and in any moment a State could consider as necessary the exit from the EU construction.
Therefore, the awarding of Nobel Peace Prize to the European Union is to be considered as a warning: if the European countries will not create a serious State (maybe a federation, maybe an unitary State), they will be reduced to an irrelevant position, and the European peace process will be questioned.
Marco Cassini
The Europen Union is a fundamental project for the mundial political and economical balance, but I think it is a profoundly incomplete construction.
ReplyDeleteThe first objective of the EU was the preservation of peace between the european countries after the Second World War.
The second objective was the increase in trade by removal of trade barriers.
At last, the third objective was to improve the quality of the life of european citizens.
First two objective has been achived but the third objective has been failed.
I hope that the Nobel Prize can to relaunch europen political integration inside the european institutions with basic support of states.
Jacopo Pieropan
From the first time I heard about the awarding of Nobel Peace Prize 2012 to the European Union, this sounded incomprehensible to me. I have not changed my opinion; there are some reasons why I still don't support the decision to give such a prize to the EU.
ReplyDeleteOfficially, what allowed the European Union to award the Nobel Peace Prize was its presumed role in "advancement of peace and reconciliation, democracy and human rights". I totally disagree with this point of view, first because I simply believe that is a lie. The first article posted at the top, taken from the american "Telegraph", underlines that the year before this awarding have been characterized by strong protests against austerity policies taken by EU members during a period of economic and financial crisis. We should not fail to mention that those mesures have been (and are) imposed by the "troika", of which the EU, in particular the frank-german axis, and BCE (another EU institution) are members, together with FMI. Police, whose violence and repression harshly hit protesters all over Europe, defended and defends decisions regarding to which EU has clear responsabilities. Probably, as the article taken form "The Guardian" affirms, the serious mistake that Oslo made, was to consider the historical, controversial however, role of that regional organization in ending conflicts, instead of analyzing its present responsabilities.
Then, we have to notice that the EU has nothing to do with Peace. The organization we are talking about is (or was) involved in various military operations all over the world, such as Eufor-Althea and Eupm in Bosnia Erzegovina, Eufor Concordia (then Eupol Proxima and Eupat) in Macedonia, Eupt Kosovo, Artemis in Congo, Amis Eu Supporting Action in Darfur, EU Bam Rafah and Eupol Copps in the Gaza Strip. We could go on mentioning those in Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan, Guinea Bissau and Moldavia-Ucraine. But that is not enough: the EU concluded agreements for strategic-military cooperation with NATO and it owns a Military Committee and a Defence Agency, which deals in interstatual cooperation concerning arms sector. Furthermore, the EU supports the growing militarisation of Europe, such as arms sales from european States to countries all around the world, projects of USA nuclear weapons, held in six EU States, and Israeli policies of occupation in Palestine. Where is Peace in all this?
The impression is that of Power that awards a prize to itself to distract attention from its actions and responsabilities. It's a vicious cycle! Maybe we should not consider Nobel Peace Prize too seriously. Better to take it for what it really is: a nonsense.
Marco Sestini
Primarily I wanted to say that perhaps many people will have been agreed and perhaps many will not for this Nobel Peace Prize for Europe, but for me the EU fully deserves it because it's precisely peace the main reason for which began it's creation. Specialy now in this period of economic crisis i think that this "symbolic" prize will be a reason more to overcome it. Now the EU is an union of peoples of many cultures and different religions, living together under common rules and common standards of democracy.Nowdays is the time in wich the european people need more to hope that this period of crisis quickly passes.Therefor this prize even if symbolic i think will motivate more the union to go ahead with integration and this moment of "weakness" can't stop it. Finding as soon as possible a common and efficient solution to overcome the crisis so that this does not repeat again is one of the targets of the EU2020 strategy.
ReplyDeleteToday we can say that the European Union is a symbol model of peace, is a feasible model which shows that if we want to collaborate even if "different" for the common good, CAN BE. This model of democracy is attracting even more countries from other continents of the world like a model to practice and yet this prize will increase even more it's international prestige.
Besmir Haxhiaj