OK, since we've been doing stereotypes I can send you this even if it's not in English! I'm very curious to know what you think about this Norwegian video which stereotypes Italians and was reported in the Repubblica!
I've always thought that this kind of Advertisement is a dreadful way to "promote" a nation abroad. The basic idea of this kind of projects is to propose to the audience a situation based on an assumption that is actually true: the fact that many more young italians choose to remain at home with their parents, for an undefined amount of time. This behaviour however is only marginally originated by the will to stay with "mamma" just because she charges herself in doing every possible kind of houseworks. For many other young people this is not a choice. It's an obligation born by the poor political actions taken in the field of welfare. In Italy some of the functions that are usually applied by the state (especially in the northern ones), are applied by families and particularly even more in this period of economic crisis. That is why I think these are not only expressions of stereotypes but pure efforts in trying to spread wrong ideas on cultures, full of destabilizing concepts that can even more and more disintegrate the feeble sense of being european citizens.
Some parts of this video can be considered like actual and rappresent the reality of italian society some other maybe are too much emphasied . I have lived in 3 different countries enough time to say that here in Italy children ( of course there are some exceptions) are educated in wrong and overprotective way. For example, the majority of my ex high school classmates were coming every morning in the school by car together with their parents. The effects of this behavior explain why I take more than one hour to reach the centre of Padua every morning while, during the school holidays, it can be reached in less than 15 minutes. In part I agree with M. De Tina when she says that italian political actions in the field of wellfare are scarce and most of us must stay at home until 30 or more years. But it's also true that some of those, mostly male, who live by theirselves, bring dirty laudry every week if not every day to their parents' home. Isn't it crazy?? There are also some mothers who clean thier childrens' home and prepare small jars of ready sauce or even meals for their “little 30- years- old child”. This behavior explains why the majority of italian men see women like someone who must clean the house, take care of children and of older members of the family without many chances to build theirown solid career. Another consequence is the lack of effective laws that protect women in all her moments of life. Statistically, in Italy, women gain less than men and occupy the lowest positions. This is not the stereothype , this is the law which is not only a formal act issued by competent authpority but also a mix of culture, beliefs and behaviors of a certain society.
I've always thought that this kind of Advertisement is a dreadful way to "promote" a nation abroad. The basic idea of this kind of projects is to propose to the audience a situation based on an assumption that is actually true: the fact that many more young italians choose to remain at home with their parents, for an undefined amount of time. This behaviour however is only marginally originated by the will to stay with "mamma" just because she charges herself in doing every possible kind of houseworks. For many other young people this is not a choice. It's an obligation born by the poor political actions taken in the field of welfare. In Italy some of the functions that are usually applied by the state (especially in the northern ones), are applied by families and particularly even more in this period of economic crisis. That is why I think these are not only expressions of stereotypes but pure efforts in trying to spread wrong ideas on cultures, full of destabilizing concepts that can even more and more disintegrate the feeble sense of being european citizens.
ReplyDeleteSome parts of this video can be considered like actual and rappresent the reality of italian society some other maybe are too much emphasied . I have lived in 3 different countries enough time to say that here in Italy children ( of course there are some exceptions) are educated in wrong and overprotective way. For example, the majority of my ex high school classmates were coming every morning in the school by car together with their parents. The effects of this behavior explain why I take more than one hour to reach the centre of Padua every morning while, during the school holidays, it can be reached in less than 15 minutes.
ReplyDeleteIn part I agree with M. De Tina when she says that italian political actions in the field of wellfare are scarce and most of us must stay at home until 30 or more years. But it's also true that some of those, mostly male, who live by theirselves, bring dirty laudry every week if not every day to their parents' home. Isn't it crazy?? There are also some mothers who clean thier childrens' home and prepare small jars of ready sauce or even meals for their “little 30- years- old child”.
This behavior explains why the majority of italian men see women like someone who must clean the house, take care of children and of older members of the family without many chances to build theirown solid career.
Another consequence is the lack of effective laws that protect women in all her moments of life. Statistically, in Italy, women gain less than men and occupy the lowest positions.
This is not the stereothype , this is the law which is not only a formal act issued by competent authpority but also a mix of culture, beliefs and behaviors of a certain society.