Word Assoc Results

Tuesday, 16 October 2012

Mapping Stereotypes

What is a stereotype? A stereotype can be defined as "a standardized mental picture that is held in common by members of a group and that represents an oversimplified opinion, prejudiced attitude, or uncritical judgment" (Merriam Webster). Another definition is "cognitive representations of another group that influence one's feeling about the group (Gudykunst and Kim). It is argued that stereotyping is a natural and universal information processing strategy that helps us make sense of a complex world. The problem with stereotyping is that they are often used to ascribe characteristics to entire groups of people and lead to ethnocentrism, prejudice and discrimination.
National stereotypes have been mapped in a project by Bulgarian artist YankoTvetskov who has created satirical maps of Europe and the world based on common national stereotypes in his Mapping Stereotypes project.



Read an interview with the artist who created these maps, YankoTvetskov and write your reflections on his project and the maps. Do you find them humorous? Offensive? Controversial? Do they serve to reinforce stereotypes or can they help us to challenge them?

22 comments:

  1. Matteo Silviotti17 October 2012 at 07:39

    Tsvetkov did a very particular work, called "mapping stereotypes", showing map charting prevailing stereotypes. He's a cosmopolitan man so his work has to be seen not as the crazy act of a humorous man, but a work from a man who knows what he's talking about.
    The first point, the first information we can take from Tsvetkov's work is the fact that some prejudices exist, they are not to be hidden , they are true and hot all around us.
    We can than think about his intention....Does he want to prove something? Or he just want to be satirical towards society?
    Well I think maybe more the second, as he says in the interview "If there is a serious problem, I prefer to present it in a funny way".
    Even if he presents these maps in a funny way they make us think about these stereotypes, which are unfortunately present in our society; they're products of history (ex. the fact that the American call the Russians "Commies") but they're also the result of the pression we receive from the media every day.
    In my opinion Tsvetkov's work must be analyzed for what it is, a funny perception and view of the world according to this alphadesigner, but remembering that what we are smiling on is something that too much times is offensive for a group of people.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tvetskov is controversial as he probably wanted it to be. The interest the journalist showed is an evidence of that. As the internet shows, it is normal for designers to turn social issues, although in this case we are talking about stereotypes, into art. I think this may be a way to show them in a different light: as for these maps Tvetskov shows how ridiculous but also dangerous stereotypes can be. Ridiculous because if we think about modern Russia we hardly think it as a communist country, we might probably think about corruption, repression, but communism is no longer the firts thing that comes in mind when we talk about Russia; dangerous because describing Algeria as Gaddafi's sperm bank, if the artist wrote what people actually think, makes the reader think that Algeria is seen as an enemy.
    To visualize through art works how shallow public opinion can be, could help to fight stereotypes. Although in my opinion this was not Tvetskov's aim. Stereotypes are usually influenced by history, culture and the relationship between countries through the years. In some cases they are caused by political fears: e.g. Europe 2022 well shows europeans' fear for the future - for example the idea of a Germanized EU, or the possibility for the EU to become to eastern-european. I found really interesting the idea of UK as Passive Aggressive Kingdom and its explanation: that has always been GB's political behaviour towards European Integration - "It doesn't want to have much to do with the continent, but it wants to have a say".

    Surely Tsvetkov's works help understand how hidious sometimes making fun of others can be, as they also do it with us.

    Annalisa Arru

    ReplyDelete
  4. This kind of maps were once popular links on the net. Tsvetkov work represented through maps, the stereotypes widely spread in our culture proposing them in a funny way. The idea beyond this project was then to amuse people by making them think about what they know (or they think they know) about other cultures. The interesting thing of this project however was also to present not an unique map with a singular point of view, but different kind of maps presenting different point of views. This is rather interesting because it let us know also how people abroad think about us. I'm rather skeptical about those who think that this maps were made to make us think or deeply reflect about our behaviour. I would rather say that this is an helpful joke created only for a good laugh and nothing more. Just not to be serious all the time ;)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Like the people who wrote above, I think that Tsvektov made these maps with the only purpose of entertaining. We all know that some kinds of stereotypes always existed, and probably always will exist: italians will always be seen as mafia members eating pizza and spaghetti from morning till night, french people as strange guys drinking wine etc. I personally don't feel humiliated when a stranger reminds me how italians are seen in other countries, but I can understand that some people may feel more offended than I could be by the same kind of "insult": it depends by the level of maturity and personal self-irony I guess. This article gives another proof of the power of Internet, if we needed more of them: a semi-unknown graphic became famous just by posting a picture on his web page. That's the interesting point in the article, from my point of view.
    Luca Marenzi

    ReplyDelete
  6. We’ve talked in class about stereotype and our way to look at other cultures. On this topic, we were showed many maps, created by the Bulgarian artist Yanko Tvetskov, which presented the world according to national stereotypes.
    In a recent interview with the journalist Tim Dowling (The Guardian), he explained that the project called “Mapping Stereotypes” was initially intended to be a joke, but had gained attention through the internet, becoming bigger and involving Europe’s as far as American’s way of thinking. Tvetskov is a designer, he has changed many places and he is used to live with people from many different countries. He said that there is nothing offensive and that the primary purpose of those maps is to entertain, to present problems in a funny way. On the other hand, the journalist seems to be offended by the project, affirming that it could reinforce and ridicule stereotypes.
    To me, I don’t think that this project should be considered as offensive or controversial; stereotyping is a natural tendency, which is even more strong if we are far from our native country. The purpose of the author is clear: he wants to lead people thinking about real problems through his art. That is what art primarily does.
    Giorgia Fontana

    ReplyDelete
  7. I liked the work of the bulgarian artist Yanko Tvetskov, I think it is a very smart reflection on the world we all live in. I think the 'mapping stereotypes' project is very entertaining. As written in the interview, the main intent of the artist is not to offend any population or culture, but to make fun of the features that we consider peculiar in people of another nationality. The artist lived his life traveling all over the world, experiencing on himself the prejudice that people from other countries may have; so his goal is not to criticize or offend, but to focus the attention of the readers on the prejudices that we all have and on the generalization that we sometimes make on other countries. With no doubt these prejudices are born from the common places and ignorance of people that don't really know much about other countries. At the same time, most of these prejudices are based on true facts ( India is in fact famous for the large use of curry in its kitchen ), people just exagerates them to make fun of other countries, and maybe even to exalt their own. The project may serve as a challenge to fight stereotypes by making people reflect on how ridiculous they are.

    Giulia Belligrandi

    ReplyDelete
  8. “Mapping stereotypes” created by Tvetskov shows the world represented through stereotypes, in particular this project reports how people from all over the world picture to themselves the other countries.
    As the author himself said, this is a way to entertain describing the world through the stereotypes that people have about other cultures, but at the same time this is a funny way to make a reflection.
    On my mind this isn’t an offensive approach to analyze the phenomenon; on the contrary, I think this project could help us to overcome ridiculous and over-simplified stereotypes about other countries and on their citizens. In fact, when you watch the maps created by Tvetskov you see a world that doesn’t exist actually (or it’s highly wide of the mark). That’s very obvious, so you can reflect about this and you can understand that stereotypes often come from distorted ideas and prejudices; so this is a funny way to consider other countries besides wrong stereotypes and to challenge them.
    On my mind, through Tvetskov’s project you can really make a reflection about the real identity of a country and its culture, challenging wrong and over-simplified stereotypes.
    Francesco Arciprete

    ReplyDelete
  9. It is good to emphasize from the outset that the purpose and the project’s scope evolved as the artist collected feedbacks from his maps.
    The idea was born in Bulgaria in 2009 as satirical complaint: “there was a gas crisis, a pretty harsh winter, and we were a little bit cold”. The idea was to let the world aware of the Bulgarian population’s condition because of the gas crisis, painting Russia as “Paranoid Oil Empire” and Europe as “competing interest and reductive presumption”. As often happen, the artist got carry away and has widened to Turkey described like “No YouTube Land” and Georgia as “Winegrowers”. At the beginning it was a politically incorrect boutade, seen the numerous reaction it turned into a serious project, producing maps charting prevailing stereotypes. At the beginning it was a political complain in satirical terms, later the stereotypes and the provoked reactions became the main object.
    As every form of committed art the purpose is to create a discussion. Reading the posted comments to the interview, people are often not agree with him. The artist’s purpose was not to be exhaustive, perfectly knowing “loads of people can analyze it way better than I can”. He just wanted to demonstrate everybody has an idea of anybody else, in the vast majority of cases distorted (“You know, what with many of them thinking the Earth is flat, and all that”). Tvetskov was perfectly aware his maps were “untrustworthy, suspect, politically incorrect”, in fact the title of the entire work could have been “why not map ignorance”? the artist himself wanted his maps controversial, humoristic and offensive.
    We must never forget the maps’ primary purpose is to entertain then, reflecting, they “could do as much to reinforce stereotypes as ridicule them”.
    Assumed the stereotype as comfortable zone, main tool to read other cultures, the idea beyond the maps in my opinion is questioning our approach: is it right to ghettoize? Up to which point? When to ghettoize starts to be dangerous? Inquiring these questions it should be considered that in both project’s stages the modus operandi is the same: to draw attention on the problem in a satirical way.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Note those who post comments on internet can be clearly divided between those who believe the idea “brilliant” and Tvetskov a “genious” and those who consider him and his art “stupid” or “annoying” even if in the second case the examples reported concern the world areas economically and politically less important only (complaints about Mongolia labeled as “savages” or Philippins as “rice dolls”. In all honesty, if I had not read comments on them I would not search for them on the map, an intrinsic sign of my stereotype about them: “they do not exist”).
    Surely the first reaction is to laugh about it but the next step is the consideration that the stereotype as a generalization can annoy. In almost all cases, except when the stereotype was molded by population whose Tvetskov was taking the point of view, it was felt narrow and awkward precisely because “not its size” but a size chosen by another culture for them.
    What I suppose the artist wanted to show is excellently summarized in a comment to the maps: “the only thing this guy got right was labeling America "The Civilized World". Almost everything else is just a weird fantasy of what American stereotypes would be”. In “The ultimate Bigot’s calendar” Tvetskov wanted to denounce the stereotype common to all people: all population around the world and in every age feel to be the world’s center and generally better than the others who have always defects.
    Annalisa wrote “to visualize could help to fight the stereotypes” arguing, however, that this one was not the purpose of the artist, that instead I think it was.
    Anyhow, in my opinion there has to be a limit that must not to be exceeded. Tvetskov and anyone else should not to be allow to have a speech about population’s dignity (“Kwpzsfrstan, Wtfstan, …stan”) and a fortiori about life’s threats, even if art is a tool to catch attention (Hunger & stuff about Kenia, AIDS about Central Africa). In some cases the denounce did not laugh, it was just one way rude.
    Particularly interesting in my opinion are the maps concerning the European Union. Two of them, the first map made by Tvetskov and the Arabic Spring one, where the European Union is called “Eutopia” fully take the stereotype that Europeans themselves have of European Union! “Crystal Ball view of Europe in 2022” then synthesizes skepticism and fears typically European, likely the only common feature within the European population where France, Germany and Northern Italy labeled as “Merkelreich”, European Union moved to the eastern countries, Turkey is still a candidate, Spain is out of the Union as Portugal and Greece. Same destiny for UK which is seen strengthened in its traditional position as “Passive aggressive Kingdom”.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I would subscribe Annalisa’s comment about Algeria, at least as regards the stereotype’s dangerousness over than ridiculousness. Describing Algeria as Gaddafi's sperm bank, it could make the reader think Algeria is seen as an enemy or threat. On the other hand this one is not a stereotype. The European stereotype about Algeria is at most “France waz here” or it can fit the American stereotype of “desert”. The “sperm bank stereotype” is exactly what I described above, a rude political satire, a stretch, not a stereotype.
    About the Norwegian advertising, there are those who may be offended by it because they do not feel reflected, others who would not be offended because they live the situation shown as normal. It is a cultural question, for certain aspect geographical one, for others generational.
    What is important to notice is that the relation considered in the advertising is mum-son, indicative cultural trait.
    According to my personal experience the advertising does not reflect me as Italian. Generally I think it is an outdated cultural trend. On the other hand it highlights an extremely current topic: musculism still pervasive in Italy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. On my point of view, the “Mapping stereotypes” is a provocative project which succeeds in the aim of destabilizing the observer’s convictions.
    Accordingly to Hegel, who argued that “Art's vocation is to unveil the truth in the form of sensuous artistic configuration”, the maps of Tsvetkov are a genuine work of art, notwithstanding their debunking power (or maybe because of it).
    In fact, the use of stereotypes as useful mental shortcuts to simplify reality is an innate process for every human being. The sense of the term can be easily deduced from its etymology; citing Katz and Braly: “The term derives from the Greek stereos, meaning solid, and tupos, meaning image or impression, from tuptein, to strike”. I don’t agree with the Merriam Webster’s definition of the phenomenon, because of its negative acceptation, since I believe that stereotypes are neutral cognitive tools.
    Consequently I don’t consider the maps offensive. Rather, for me they are an ironic description of our mental oversimplifications. Of course, it’s quite difficult to remain indifferent to some trenchant labels but, as suggested by Tim Dowling, the author of the interview to the artist, “No matter where you're from, you should be able to find something here to offend you”.
    Initially I felt annoyed when I saw that my home town region had been placed by Tsvetkov under the name “Ethiopia” in the “Europe according to Italians map”. I revived myself from my blind rancour when I realized that I was thinking that maybe the artist has known only northerners, “because people from Veneto are all racist”. “Briefly, I was rebelling against stereotypes using a stereotype as weapon!
    Therefore, I think that playing with our prejudices trough the “Mapping stereotypes” project is an excellent way to awaken from our cognitive inertia and motivate ourselves to discover the truth hidden under our preconceptions.

    ReplyDelete
  13. from my point of view, this project intends to give pause to communities in an ironic way, of the stereotypes present and possible visions of people and people outside of our community may have.
    on the one hand could be considered offensive, at least at first glance, but consider it as an incentive to develop new forms of interaction that eliminate or prove to eliminate stereotypes.
    the video on the propensity of the Norwegians to see ourselves as the mammon I find it ironic and not offensive, it is for our young "boys" to show that it is not, it is an incentive.

    I apologize for the delay

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with the images on this blog loading?

    I'm trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog.
    Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

    my page; social bookmarking service

    ReplyDelete
  15. Ι evеry timе spent my half an hоur to rеaԁ this weblog's content all the time along with a mug of coffee. http://Www.tinnitus411.com/stop-ringing-in-the-ears/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Usually I don't learn post on blogs, however I would like to say that this write-up very pressured me to try and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, quite great post. http://www.tinnitus411.com/remedy-for-ringing-in-the-ears/
    My website > http://www.tinnitus411.com/remedy-for-ringing-in-the-ears/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Greetings from Idaho! I'm bored at work so I decided to check out your blog on my iphone during lunch break. I love the knowledge you provide here and can't wait to take a
    look when I get home. I'm surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my mobile .. I'm not
    even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, great site!

    Take a look at my website: Forex Trading System

    ReplyDelete
  18. Your mode of explaining all in this paragraph is actually fastidious,
    every one be able to effortlessly understand it, Thanks a lot.


    my blog league of legends download

    ReplyDelete
  19. I was moгe than hаppy to uncovеr this
    gгeat site. І wantеd tο thanκ you for οnеs time just
    for thіs fаntastic геad!! Ι ԁefinitelу savorеԁ everу part
    of it and i also have you boοk marκed tο loοk at new things οn
    your ѕite. click the following document

    ReplyDelete
  20. Superb, what a weblog іt is! This ωebρage ρresents hеlpful dаta
    tо us, kеep it up. www.besthemorrhoidcare.com/thrombosed-external-hemorrhoid/

    ReplyDelete
  21. When I initially сommenteԁ I cliсkеd the "Notify me when new comments are added" checkbox and now each time a comment іs аdded I get seѵeral e-mailѕ with the
    same сomment. Is there аny waу you can remοve people from that
    sеrvісе? Cheers! How do you stop armpit sweating fast

    ReplyDelete
  22. For the reason that the admin of this web page is working,
    no question very shortly it will be famous,
    due to its feature contents.

    Feel free to surf to my web site email Console

    ReplyDelete