Word Assoc Results

Tuesday, 4 December 2012

The future of political and social sciences


Next week is supposed to be dedicated to the improvement of university teaching and I'd like to open a discussion with you on this topic, also in view of the event which will be taking place in the Department on the 14th and 15th December, the Future of Political and Social Sciences, which is part of a broader project: Next Generation Global Studies. I'd like you to consider how you think this university could help you to become critical, creative and responsible global citizens and political scientists. What and how would you like to learn? What is the role of foreign languages in this process? New technologies? Global networks?
Here are a couple of videos to get you thinking, please comment with your thoughts on this topic and try to start a dialogue about this which we can continue in class. You could also think about making a short collective statement  - in the form of a document, a video, a powerpoint... the possibilties are endless - which could be presented at some point during the event.  






19 comments:

  1. There are two images that come to my mind when I think about Italian university: disposable notions and male power. The former is tightly linked to the late capitalistic logic that dominates our modernity, the latter is a direct consequence of centuries of patriarchal structure of gender relations.
    Modernity is characterized by commodification and reification of everything that surrounds us and I think that we can find this typical (and tragic) aspect even in our universities. Our faculties look like point-factories that sell us University Credits (CFU) and we seem to be anxious consumers playing our role in a frenetic rush. We are given disposable notions, information we use in order to get points (CFU) and then we throw them away (in a way that is inherent in capitalistic and consumerist logic). Far from giving us the possibility to practice a conscious and critical thought, our courses (with very few exceptions) are power instruments. I mean that they are often demonstrations of power (as often as not of male power). I am referring to courses held by professors who base their work on frontal lectures, on books that they themselves write and so on... Professors who want students to say what they themselves have said in class (and this is the same of what they have written in their books- no alternative opinions!), or those who want students to attend their courses even if they are utterly insignificant (as they are terribly self-referential). Sometimes you are given the promise-or is it a threat?- that if you attend the course you will have a special treatment during the exam, or that if you go to lessons every day you will have to read a book less. And this is a utter nonsense! I find these dynamics nothing but asking and giving deference.
    I think that there should be more workshop-based courses and I have a different take on giving these workshops an extra special value. They should be completely and deeply free: no extra rewards (this will lead to more responsibility)!
    Another problem is that information we are given are often expression of the dominant thought: it seems that there is no space for alternative and innovative thoughts. Some examples of absent (or nearly absent) subjects include those linked to gender and women studies, to identity and ethnicity or to global studies. I am pretty sure that hybrid figures should be developed and enhanced as we are facing social and global challenges that require new and different analysis.
    What is more, most of our courses are grounded on an Eurocentric perspective. I am fully convinced that it is time to overcome perspectives that present western culture as the only model of and for civilisation.
    That is to say that I reckon that our university, as it is nowadays, cannot make us critical, creative and responsible global citizens (nor can our society!). So we should try to enhance new forms of critical thought that can develop complex analysis and, finally, conscious action.
    As a consequence, in such a perspective, foreign languages have an unavoidable importance as they are essential keys that can help us to open new horizons.
    As far as new technologies are concerned, I have always been reluctant to consider them as neutral or positive instruments. I am referring in particular to social networks that I consider typically modern forms of mystification of reality and social relations. However, I recognize that there are some technologies that could act as platforms where students can interact with professors (and with other students as well) in a constructive and responsible (and conscious!) way, even building new global networks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In the last lesson some students started to talk about new arguments such as the important of our University's courses or the necessity to know the English. What does it mean? Someone expressed his thought on several kinds to teach. The discussion was very interesting. So, the teacher asked us to write a comment about Political Science’s future. Perhaps, I think, because the next week there will be the evaluation of university courses. So, this is a good opportunity to reflect on our student career. In fact, the question was: How is Political science faculty? Does it have the right structure? Did we choose really that what we want? And also, are we satisfied of the studies or of the teachers? It’s possible to change anything? We try to answer to these various questions.
    During these days I have read some articles regarding Political Science’s studies and in particular I have focused on foreign Universities' offer. In this way I could to compare the different approach to teach. In addition, I put attention on Britain's schools as LSE school and Cambridge University. In both we can find the Political Science courses. Before to write about these, I would to explain what it means to study Political Science.
    I think that when you study Political Science, you will be able to learn about how political power is distributed, how different governments operate and interact, how rules are made and enforced. Today it’s very important to understand this. We are living in a difficult political and economical phase where several countries as Italy, Spain and in particular Greece, don’t grow. Today, many people are unhappy and they haven't security on the future. Is it really possible to exit from this crisis? Certainly, we know this depends about how governments implement politics. In my opinion this is one of the reasons to study Political Science. We need understand! Perhaps, in this way we’ll try to change and improve our life. We must believe in the future.
    In fact, studying Political Science we will explore the “who” of politics such as politicians, international organizations etc, and the “How” such as elections, political institutions and public administration. Politics interests many aspects of our lives, including the availability of education, jobs, healthcare and more other.
    But, what is Political Science? It’s the study of political ideas, events, actions, and institutions. It includes both understanding and explaining the world of politics that is around us. We all participate in politics, though most of the time we do so unknowingly. Politics is much more than simply voting in an election or working in government. Reading or listening to news, talking with friends and family about social issues and values are a few of the many examples of political activity in our everyday lives. Well, for this reason, I think that to study Political Science is very useful for us. And this is valid also for the future.
    Why? Because studying Political Science we discuss on basic concepts such us democracy, government, or power. We’ll find again these important words or concepts in the future.
    Also, I think that Political Science can open up various job opportunities in both public and private sectors. Students interested in careers in business, education, law, communications, government, or politics more generally will obtain important and useful knowledge and skills.
    I continue in my blog where we can find also a short description about two British schools. It's an interesting example of Political and social courses.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nowadays our faculty is offering us a general education on various matters, without specialising on any given subject. For example a degree path may focus on economy, financial services and so on, and then contain a course that talks about sociology, an interesting matter, but that has nothing, or almost nothing, to do with the rest of the courses.
    This fact might be seen from a double perspective: we can extend our knowledge on different themes, gaining maybe a deeper analysing and critical skill, but we may exit from university at the same time without a precise definition of our future role in the "world of work", using an Italian expression.
    What would I change in the faculty of Political Sciences? I'd organise every course degree in a more specialised way, keeping an eye to the work sector where they will introduce their students, in a way that could help to develop some useful working skill, and cutting so any course that may not be strongly linked with the others.
    Talking about language courses, my guess is that the only language that must be known by a graduate in Political Science should be English: forcing students to learn and know a second foreign language that they most probably won't use ever in the future is a nonsense from my point of view. The benefit of mastering English is well known, and should be achieved by any graduate from any course of the entire university in my opinion; but I honestly can't see the utility of knowing a third language (assuming that the student should write and speak Italian properly), when the rest of the world uses only English for their international relationships: I'm not saying that they should be completely cut off the faculty, but imposing one of them as a mandatory exam is an error. I would change them as an optional exam.
    Another topic that emerged from the discussion we had in classroom was about the time schedule of exams: I totally agree with our colleagues, when they said that our approach to the exams is now reduced to a sort of rush to complete our courses and pass their final tests. Having two or three exams in the same week, sometimes in the same day, doesn't help to master a given matter, which should be the purpose of the university: I would personally prefer a course reorganisation that could let us deepen a subject, such as having an exam per month, but I also understand that this hypothesis would involve heavy problems of coordination between the various courses.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This week I have found many articles but in particular many demonstrations that talk about the future of the students, the future of the university and what think the students about this matter. The vision of the university is changed a lot in comparison to once, the conception of the job is changed. There were a lot of less degrees and many less diplomas, today the students get almost all the diploma. The same university to bureaucratic level is changed, there are not the courses of degree anymore to "unique cycle" but they have been introduced "3+2", three years for the bachelor and two for the master. Our faculty in fact before it was to 4 year-old unique cycle and now become "3+2." I think that this has not been a good idea because with the bachelor many students stop here and they don't continue and so they leave "incomplete" their run of studies. My opinion is that they had to maintain the courses of degree to unique cycle. But the negative aspect of the political science is the organization of the exam because a lot of times there are two exams the same day and to the same times. And for the students it is a very problem. However this university has always offered great opportunities to the students, particularly our faculty has offered and offers stage or erasmus, where the students are able for some months to face the real life and working in concrete. I think that Italian university is a good university to organizational level and cognitive level; to linguistic level however my opinion is that it should more develop. The Italian problem is that we don’t use any languages in the real life in comparison to other countries and I think that it is a very problem. It would need to develop this aspect. I think that to the university the courses of language are different in comparison to the other courses and that the relationship with the teachers is different in comparison to the others.

    Benfatto Elena

    ReplyDelete
  5. Our university and specifically political science department offers a great deal of courses whose subjects and goals are different so the consequence is that students of political science, unlike for example the one of medicine department, can have different objectives.
    Exactly since political science regards law, economy, history, sociology, etc. allows you to become more critical and nowadays in a global society it is really the key.
    The most important thing to became critical is obviously knowledge. In a video a student says that only a small percentage of books read will be useful in her life. I don’t agree with this statement, she can’t really know that yet, maybe she could say that in some years.
    I can honestly say that in every course I took, I have learnt something. I am truly convinced that none of the subjects that I have studied, has been useless. In some cases I was sceptical about the content of the courses, but then at the end I realized the importance of each one.
    This helped me realize that the first thing in order to become critical in a positive way is to be curious and be willing to understand matters of things and wait to get to the conclusion. University should encourage this aspect that is to lead us in order to have a critical thinking. To reach this goal, new technologies are useful, but not enough.
    Books are still, in my opinion, the fundamental key of knowledge and the net could complete that. I also believe that classroom lessons are important. When reading we are alone like when we are surfing the net, instead a classroom lesson allows dialogue and also gives you the possibility to share knowledge with a more emotional involvement.
    A classroom lesson allows not only to create a connection with your professor but also among students, it gives more emotions and energy, and this allows you to create relationship and this is good not only for your mind but also for the soul too. The professor can enable this and also convey passion to students for the subject, but then of course it depends on each one curiosity.
    Foreign languages knowledge is crucial to get new information ad open up your mind, not only to keep in touch with those that are on the other side of the world, and to support battles from a distance, but also to get news from world. In fact if you read Italian online newspaper, except for some aspects of the EU or events that have a great emphasis such as presidents’ election, civil revolutions, in short sensational news, you will notice that there isn’t any news about foreign issues. Instead, if you read foreign online newspapers, you will find worldwide news. So if we want to really find out what is happening outside our borders languages knowledge is essential.

    Cristina Patron

    ReplyDelete
  6. In my opinion university should both give students the tools necessary to understand the world they are surrounded from, and those they need to interact with and change it. Nowadays University only provides us with a method of understanding, but most of the times it is inadequate to have an inner knowledge of modern society. Political science courses should create the next generation of statists, but it is seen as an easy degree even by those who organize courses. Many exams tend to be not enough specializing or connected to modern world, even languages sometimes are considered not that important. Even though the only way to understand a globalized society is to understand the language it speaks, we continue thinking that learning languages is marginal, something that should be done only by the one who will actually interact with foreigners.

    As for job opportunities, I think University should be more connected to the job market. Connections with businesses are fundamental to make students grow in a more critical and analytic way. Internships should be mandatory for all degree courses and be organized to be specific for the career chosen by the students.
    I am afraid that creativity cannot be “taught” at University, but it should be developed and supported in primary and secondary schools. University should help it emerge and improve.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In these two videos we watched pros and cons of new technologies in the university. What could new technologies do to help the students?
    The first video is about the inadequacy of university system that isn't able to exploit new technologies (for example the video shows a student that admits he uses his pc to surf on the internet and on social networks during the lessons). The second video offers a lot of examples about the utility of new technologies and above all about the internet. I think that internet has been a big discovery and that it has revolutionized our way of getting news from outside, but at the same time I think that it can be dangerous and that it can also spread false informations. So we have to be able to use internet and to recognize what is true and what is false. I chose to study political sciences for two reasons: the first one was that I wanted to know more about the international political systems and the second one was that I wanted to learn foreign languages. Foreign languages are essential in a course of political sciences because it's necessary to have a good level of english to work in international organizations or institutions of the European Union. For this reason I don't understand why in our university the english course lasts only one semester. We should have the possibility to study english for the whole three years (in the first level degree) and for the whole two years (in the second level degree). Another problem is the different level of english of students in the same class. On the one hand there are students that speak english fluently but on the other hand many students have a lot of difficulties. This difference brings about two problems: students that are very good in english are slowed down by students that have a low level, while other students have to make a big effort to keep the pace of their class mates. Generally speaking italian students have a lower english level than other european students (I am thinking about students of north and west Europe) and I don't think that the problem is that we are less "smart" than other students. Even if we studied english for ten years (we start to study it at the elementary school) when we arrive at the university we can't speak english. The problem is in the teaching of subject (for example the teachers of english should be only native speakers and they should speak only english during the all lesson). Surely the solution for italian students could be to go in erasmus or to do summer school in England or in the USA. These solutions are very expensive, and being very hard to learn a language only by studying it at school, a solution could be to read books and to watch movies in the original language.

    Belligrandi Giulia

    ReplyDelete
  8. The topic suggested by Prof. Helm is quite provocative, especially for us as young students of Political and Social Sciences. I won’t write either about educational reforms that the government shold do, nor about insufficient resources, nor about wrong setting of the courses, which are most of the time, only theoretical and repetitive. Italian universities are well known all over the world because they prepare students who are highly trained on theory, but poor on practice, and because they don’t help students to become critical and creative.
    In this regard, I’d like to share with you some thoughts I’ve had when I was in Berlin and I was attending some courses at the Freie Universitaet with the Erasmus Programme. The first impression of the way of teaching and studying there was unexpected: the lectures I was attending were easy to follow, the concepts explained were elementary, and the teacher was spending half of the time asking opinions and discussing with the students. I was disappointed because what I expect from a lecture is to learn new theories and not to share my personal opinions with other students who know as much as me.Then, after one month, I realized I was wrong. The course of Comparative Politics I attended was held by Prof. Miranda Schreurs, who is the Director of the Environmental Policy Research Centre at the FU Berlin University (and who maybe worths your attention because of her interesting life and her engagement in the field of environmental researches – for more information you can read an interview here
    http://www.iges.or.jp/en/news/event/isap2012/interactive_m.html – ),
    the participants were students from many different countries, the language of instruction was english, and the great thing of that course was that I’ve learned more there than studying just theories on books. First of all the professor had the merit of having challenged us with discussions on topics which are central either for our field of study and for our everyday life (such as global movements, role of political parties, importance of constitution, gender equality and so on): I had the chance of hearing many different experiences from people who came from places far from Europe, also, with whom I couldn’t have spoken in other occasions. We were also asked to write some essays on those topics, and that was a way to deepen them and to focus our attention on those aspects we believe more relevant. I really appreciate this teaching method, it has made me more conscious and critical on everydaylife facts, and thanks to that, I’ve became more curious and open to other people’s opinions.
    In conclusion, I think that Italian universities should learn from other European ones, they should be more open to new partnerships and have more foreign professors who, hopefully, can held their lectures in english. This would be a great chance to improve teaching quality, to make students familiar with english and with other way of teaching, and to open our horizonts.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I frequently thought about the university in relation to the others abroad and to the future challenges . I also thought about the orthodox methods of learning. Above all, teachers sometimes speak without creating a debate with its students.
    Nowadays the university would integrate the global changes with learning: innovation, technology, globalization. In their free times students usually spend their time with pc, Internet and new technologies. It means they are predisposed to innovation and to using technology better than for example a book. The blog project is an example. This project allows me to take a lot of information in English. I have to read articles, texts and listen to videos. I have to understand and then I have to explain my opinions and the information taken on websites. It is an alternative way for improving my languages skills and my vocabulary. It is a new and interactive method for learning. In addition, I can improve my knowledge about a topic it interests me.
    I think the university has a responsibility: it could help students to become critical and responsible global citizens. The role of teaching is linked to educate the students understanding local and global issues and the exact approach to handle the “external world” (job, other studies…). The university could give the instruments for handling successfully interviews, debates and the challenges. The students would have the knowledge to access into the world out of the safety of the university and for understanding economic, social and political problems.
    The foreign languages have an important role: learning would have an international connotation and the globalization had the role to mainstream different cultures and languages. The intercultural communication is very important in every environment, from university to job.
    The students would have awareness of the positive instruments to develop critical thoughts and to take part in a civil society that participate and take global responsibility. In this way it is important rethinking education.

    Francesca Villani

    ReplyDelete
  10. I came to a conclusion: the university didn’t give me anything from a personal and internal point of view. Our academic career is characterized by books, solitary study and lack of opportunity to become, first of all, citizens.
    This aspect is more important if we consider that we are Political Sciences’ students: a faculty that would give the instruments to become critical and active people. After the high school, I had great expectation about this faculty. It’s true that the University of Milan, in which I studied for my bachelor degree, is too dispersive: a frontal lesson with, more or less, 150-200 students, doesn’t give the possibility to ask questions. Things change when the university is smaller and, consequently, the relationship between university professors and students is different. But at the end, the result is the same.
    We have to gain knowledge through books, it’s a fundamental step but sometimes it’s an alienating activity: I ask myself in which way I’ll use all these theoretical constructs in a real working field.
    In real life, employers don’t ask if you are good to studying but if you have the capability to work in group, to have the instruments to solve problems, to be practical worker and not theoretical one.
    Each student has the same aim: to pass the exams in time and to have a good result; of course, this point is important but the system doesn’t work. The university is only a competition, in which intelligence is linked with the ability to gain an high score: we pass a lot of our precious time to memorize concepts, without the time and the possibility to put them in a context or to criticized them.
    New technologies can’t be useful in that sense: they can help students and university professors to have a continue communication or they can help students to do researches, but they are not the key to change the situation.
    The solution is in the university itself: a lot of university professors consider teaching as an hobby, like gardening; they have their own career and they teach only because it’s an annoying step of their personal fulfillment. Of course, there is the other side of the coin: there are professors who try to stimulate students. I think that the verb “to stimulate” is the perfect one to describe students’ need.
    Political Sciences faculty also has positive aspect: it’s a multidisciplinary course of study that gives a mental agility because we are able to analyze a particular element from different points of view. Our sociological, economic, political “knowledge” can help us to have an overview on general aspects.
    But this positive aspect is not sufficient; it exists only because Political Sciences embraces different subjects.
    The English course is fundamental, expecially for us but the question is: is it possible that, during the bachelor degree, I followed an English course for four months and, during my master here in Padua, others four months? Is it possible that in five years, I study English only for eight months? In our course, English should be a permanent course to become more fluent and more “international”.
    In summary, university professors should be more active with the aim to stimulate students; the system should give useful instruments to become future good workers; English should be a stable course and we should be more active in spite of everything.

    Maria Corriero

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The topic “future of political and social sciences” gives me the opportunity to voice some reflections, which have been stratified in five years of attendance of Political Sciences’ Faculty at University of Padova. According to this and after having redden some commenting posts and heard the short movies related to the topic posted on the main blog, I think that dividing the paper in two parts is the most intelligible way to inquire the topic: what is wrong or supposed to be with University in my opinion and how it could be, trying a future’s divination.
    Budgetary cuts, reforms, adaptation to European standards made our University change a lot, and not only in a positive way. The feeling I have felt from the very beginning of my experience as undergraduate student is that University is like a factory and me and my closest colleagues were used to call it “Degrees’ Factory”. We were and are like battery-chicken, forced to soak up the information given us in a time far shorter than the one necessary to comprehend the matter and to develop a critical thought about it. The worst thing in the University is just this one: even if you are asked to have a critical thought you do not have the tools or the time to develop it. Time to get a degree got shorter and rhythm increased. The result is ranks of students memorizing in a short time huge amount of information in order to pass the exam, forgetting everything or the most in a mouth. That is a problem, speaking generally. Yet it is not necessarily a bad thing. Like everything, University is a tool and as such, the outcome depends on its use. I think the problem is wider and deeper. It is not only speed, rhythm, quality of teaching. More students because of more money means more and more different educational and cultural levels and allowing everybody to get e degree provokes lower and lower teaching level. Here stands the problem in my opinion: the highest level of education is not for everyone. At least talking about education we should abandon the assuring approach, not everybody are fit for University.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Personally I noticed a tendency and I think is a good one. During the first degree level – triennale – the teaching is notional and rigid. I have found it very effective and it gave me the fundamental knowledge to start the highest level of university teaching. Magistrale is definitely less linked to text-book and more focus on current event and application of what we learnt and are learning to the reality, a more dynamic way to learn. It is true that it is not possible to develop a critical thought about everything in a faculty where a critical think is more important almost than studying itself. Following the same division, during the first three years classes are almost exclusively frontal classes, during magistrale Professors themselves try interaction as way to teach and critical confrontation. We are forced to develop a critical thought, thus being updated and conscious about what is going on around us. Personally I have almost always found Professor trying to be innovative, forcing themselves to give us as widest view as possible. When it is not this one the situation given, I think it is not honest to empty all responsibilities on University and at the same time it should be personal pride to deepen by themselves, considering that attending our (former) Faculty we are supposed to do it anyway.
    And now how university could be, thinking about the world today, educational system today and which role technology can play in it. The problems of University are, at different levels, the same all over the world: number of students attending classes, personal-impersonal way to teach, attention’s level while attending classes, quality of teaching, books or material to be studied, economical student’s condition, how to organize life while studying, job after graduation. At least these are the problems of the old university. Nowadays the university teaching is more and more merging with technology so it is impossible to say how technology will influence educational system since they are getting the same thing. As it is said in the short movies above, “we don’t know where we are” and where we are going and how fast. The role of information technology is growing exponentially and we are just beginning to recognize applications and implications of it. What is certain is that in five years we changed from check exam’s result on a paper hang on a wall to know it checking our own personal page on the website of our university, from studying on books only to download the material that professor send us by mail. In this moment internet is the main source of information – knowledge – culture – society – everything! ad university is deeply involved in the process, from buying books on eBay, working on internet platform, to searching for everything on the web. At this regard we could say today university is wikiuniversity already, leading to a world where the knowledge is sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I cannot divine phenomenon’s evolution and at this stage an analysis could be an hazard, it is necessary educational engineering for that. What is certain is that technology could be a good and useful tool as a bad one (reliable sources or not – in a world like “wiki” one, where everybody is free to charge anything freely – misleading use, wrong sources..) as everything else. Matter of fact, technology is getting more and more important in all life’s areas. The foreseeable future for university is cyber learning, partly reality today. What I am referring to are Degree’s courses held sending to students material or classes on videoconference, available all over the world. It has to be verified if the teaching quality and learning level would remain the same or improve but still, they are reality.
    To sum up what above, my idea of University rebuilding is a more selective system with a first level degree ensuring solid basic knowledge and a second level degree where sharing and interacting are effective and worthwhile processes. A good answer in my opinion could be “the right half” between notional study and a more dynamic and creative one emerging from debates and fresh news. Later, we will see if we will be requested to study on books or something different, in same classroom or each of us in his/her country, attending the same class divided by millions of kilometers.
    About the role of foreign languages in the University changing process I refer to what I wrote commenting the post “Italian University switches to English” on “Little Italy” blog.

    Valentina Lonardi

    ReplyDelete
  16. In order to give an answer somewhat complete, in my opinion it is necessary to do some preliminary considerations.
    First of all, the role assigned to University has changed through the decades. In the first part of twentieth century, Universities were the top-level educational institutions, and even the most qualified jobs and works could be carried out without an university education.
    University students were the social elite, both for origin and for future employments. Therefore, universities could be considered as places of almost pure academic research and intellectual production.
    Around the middle of the century, University greatly changed its role. Due to technical improvement and to social complexity increase, qualified works and jobs were to be carried out only by people with university education, and university itself shifted from the uppermost layer of social hierarchy to a upper-middle one.
    Nowadays, University is designed and intended in order to educate lower-middle level technicians (in the broader meaning of the word), officials and bureaucrats, both of public and private sector. The real advanced education is given in the post-degree education, as well as the real research is carried out in a way severely distinct from the ordinary teaching.
    Beyond the general purpose of the university education, it is necessary to try to analyze the role of Political Science studies. These studies, at university level, are intended to educate and to obtain future "grunts" who should be able to carry out the mass work which is necessary to the maintenance of the society: bureaucrats, both private and public, consultants, social researchers. Only the most elite courses train future high-level officials, such as (wannabe) diplomats and other figures.
    At the present days, university Political Science is able to provide students with some basic understanding tools, which are deemed fit enough for mid level workers, but are clearly not sufficient for a deep comprehension of the social environment which we live in.
    However, there is a clear difficulty: nowadays request of higher specialization is increasing, and even the lowermost-level bureaucrats are required to have some decision-making capabilities.
    These capabilities cannot be acquired through the present-day university Political Science courses and studies. First of all, an easy course cannot, by definition, educate students at a sufficient level. Secondarily, despite some efforts taken with the Process of Bologna, courses are still too general and dramatically too theoretical.
    The fact that in the best cases courses require two foreign language exams and do not include mandatory exams to be taught in a foreign language, indicates that political science courses are anchored in the distant past, when an official could easily deal with his/her job without being able to speak at least two languages.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Last year I spend two semesters in France in one of the best Political Sciences University that it's possible to find in France. I was in Strasbourg at “Science Po Institute” and I felt very lucky to pass one year in that school. At the begging I didn't know that that school was actually so prestigious but I've started to realized that after few week because every person that I met he was impressed by that fact I was studying there. Actually even me I was positively shocked when I understood that to be a political science student in France it was or better it is completely different from to be the same student in Italy. This experience taught me so many different things but above all to be able to look with critical eyes the values and faults of two different university system and to try to take the best from both.
    So I would like to describe what I really appreciated about french university system at Science Po Institute. I definitely loved the fact that there were a lot of courses in which the professors used foreign languages linked with the subject for example “Latin America History” was taught in Spanish, “South Africa Issues” in English “Post-communism matters in Russia” in Russian and so on. In my opinion this it was amazing in fact I think that it really pushes the students to improve their personal skill on using daily different languages above all because lots of these courses were compulsory. Then I appreciated the fact that it was compulsory to pass one year abroad and I deeply convinced, after passing one year abroad, that this is the best way for a student that is studying Political science to open his mind in order to better understand what surrounds him and how different could be the life even if you move only few miles from your native town. Finally I was impressed by the fact that, even if they were younger than me, french students have done many stages during their first years and they were used to follow rhetoric course in order to improve their ability to talk in public. In fact I believed that french student are highly knowledgeable to face the work world.
    Therefore strong point of Italian system is the fact that the study is very detailed and in-depth one. In fact when I was in France I never studied books with hundreds of pages. So I can say that we have a better theoretical preparation.
    Finally I would like to underline the fact that in my opinion it's very important to improve the link between university and work world with internships or workshop because in this way students could improve not only their theoretical knowledge but also practical skill.

    Annie Ishebabi

    ReplyDelete
  18. errata corrige: after reading some commenting posts and watching the videos related to.. (first para of my comment)

    ReplyDelete
  19. According to me, there are some elements that make, in the school so as in the university, the traditional teaching method inadequate to educate people to critical thought. First of all, sciolistic knowledge, for which the current teaching system works, leads to a unimaginative studying, in which the student repeats the lesson without a real and serious reflection on the object of his/her learning. Probably the great working load, doesn't allow us to really enjoy our studies, because after an exam we have to prepare us for another one and so on... Maybe, there's a need to slow down even the learning rhythm in the sense I have just explained.
    Secondly, instead of only frontal lessons, we should experiment interactive and horizontal ways of learning, like working in groups, workshops and experiments which could allow us to learn from each other.
    Then, I notice that academic knowledge, in most of cases, is oriented only to the Market and doesn't prepare students to think critically. University is often thought as the "antechamber" of the firm.
    The authoritarian and hierarchical method on which our society is built, rules the traditional teaching system, too. This is a method, in which competion grows, whose aim is to guide the individual to an uncritical acceptance of reality, of the dialectic command/obedience, of the status quo. Definitively, the uncritical acceptance of the present social order.

    ReplyDelete